Discussion about this post

User's avatar
Dr. K's avatar

Vinay has come a long way in this regard -- he used to say it was "bioplausible". I have never even reached that point, because rabbits' feet are "luckoplausible", too. The evidence has been there for decades that masking has no discernable effect.

The fundamental crisis that we are all seeing now has its roots in the epidemiologic community NOT coming out right away and saying "NO, this is balderdash". By just standing aside (most of them) and not crying foul right out the gate, the path was prepared for an increasing number of greater lies -- all of which were bought hook, line, and sinker by most and those who didn't buy them were silenced.

The harm has been untold. If we do anything, it should be getting EVERY doc, and certainly every epidemiologist who should have read this literature, to get up and say "What you were told about masking was a lie. Masks have never had any value. Ignore any directions to the contrary -- they are not supported by science". If enough people (Makary is saying this bluntly these days, but so many are silent) got up and shouted this from every rooftop, eventually it would be too many to be silenced.

Short this, we are just in for more of the same. The masking case is clear and has been known for generations. It is time to stand on good medical principles -- or there will likely not be another opportunity as the government cookbook tells you what to say/do. (Of course, vaccine mandates and de-licensing are the obvious, and happened, end point of this -- but wait until it is applied to everything by the megalomaniacs who think they know better than each individual doctor/patient relationship.)

I am begging all the doctors that read this blog to take off the masks and disallow them in your office (I have never had them in there) and to start explaining the difference between truth and lies to your patients. Otherwise, medical practice will fall just like public health is falling (and it should).

Expand full comment
Michael DAmbrosio's avatar

How many more years will this pseudoscience prevail though? It’s become part of the unscientific zeitgeist - you’d have more luck convincing the general public that nuclear energy is safe, roundup doesn’t cause cancer, or the marvel movies aren’t very good than getting to realize their talisman is this generations rabbits foot.

Expand full comment
15 more comments...

No posts