13 Comments
User's avatar
Druin Burch's avatar

I'm heartened to see someone else expressing scepticism for antidepressants that haven't been tested against active placebos.

Dan's avatar

I get that same nausea when my stocks crater.

Paulette Altmaier's avatar

Very true, Vinay. I have found AI (Grok) incredibly helpful to help me understand and deal with what happened when a close 75 year old relative was misdiagnosed with Parkinson's based on a superficial criterion by a really bad neurologist who prescribed Syndopa for him. He and went into psychosis within a few days.

Grok helped us a lot by telling us this was a common reaction to Syndopa. In addition, his range of strange symptoms as his brain heals would have had his wife in despair - except Grok has provided the information that these are not unusual when recovering from psychosis at that age. It provided more detailed info than the doctors did, which helped reassure us, even though his new doctors were treating him correctly - stopped the Syndopa, provided careful and conservative care to help his brain heal without throwing lots of drugs at him.

Grok also told me to go to the ER, not just email my dr, when I had 2 thunderclap headaches. I would never have thought of doing so on my own.

So it has its place and has been very helpful for me and I am sure many others. But there do seem to be some very silly highly publicized case studies - you've highlighted several already.

Ben T's avatar

I mean, you're basically right. But consider that most medical visits are very brief, and this one involved a language barrier (which further limits how much communication you can do in a limited time). So in the real world...

Indigestion or similar complaints are usually just going to get a cookbook approach, like a few labs and imaging and maybe an EGD.

Diving into things like functional dyspepsia requires detailed discussions and keeping journals and the like, which is not really what doctors do. So most doctors would tend to miss that type of thing, or just consider it a less-important potential "diagnosis of exclusion" after they've done all the other tests etc.

Mark's avatar

If a doctor has never seen a case of poison Ivy and never heard of fibromyalgia (most never think about this diagnosis), they would not come up with the diagnosis on their own, regardless of how easy it would be for any doctor or lay person who saw it before.

Sharon Royal's avatar

“A case of getting older.” So, that’s what I have, lol.

J OLeary's avatar

This shows that the first thing that should be repalced by AI is the NEJM!

Cidgee's avatar

My 87 year old mother has dealt with severe nausea, migraines and dizziness since she was in her early twenties. In all of these years no doctor has been able to help her. No one asked enough questions to put the pieces together. In desperation after she had a bad bout of nausea without headache that lasted over a month I had a session with AI. It asked a lot of questions, including medical history and finally suggested vestibular migraine but thought she should also get a neurological assessment to be on the safe side. I had AI provide a synopsis that listed her history, symptoms, changes, things that make the symptoms worse etc. She took this to the doctor who said that sounded about right and prescribed a med that she can take with the first onset of symptoms. She was at the end of. her rope. Now she has renewed interest in life. AI might have problems but this is one area that holds a lot of promise.

ravi sahay's avatar

Well, if AI comes up with a cure for Fibromyalgia, that is most welcome!

Paul Driscoll's avatar

As a retired family physician, I am amazed that Dr Nundy had never diagnosed or treated functional dyspepsia before. I have seen it hundreds of times. Treatment is a bit of a shot in the dark, since there really are no good studies of the recommended medications. I have used both TCA’s and SSRI’s, depending on associated symptom. Since this does appear to be a psychophysical disorder, TCA’s or SSRI’s seem like a reasonable choice. Even if the placebo effect here is large, if the patient does better and experiences no adverse effects, I would not hesitate to use them.

Paul Driscoll's avatar

Actually I may have been a bit harsh in criticizing Dr Nundy. She was dealing with a significant language barrier, even with an online interpreter. This makes making a nuanced diagnosis rather difficult.

Hansang Bae's avatar

"I am also surprised NEJM published the case without appropriate balance."

When will NOT be surprised, doctor?

James Jones's avatar

"There is a new essay in the New England Journal of Medicine— That's actually a real journal-"

really? I thought it was just a marketing exercise to promote new drugs of big pfarma; you think it is real? Gosh;

2009: Marcia Angell

"It is simply no longer possible to believe much of the clinical research that is published, or to rely on the judgment of trusted physicians or authoritative medical guidelines. I take no pleasure in this conclusion, which I reached slowly and reluctantly over my two decades as an editor of The New England Journal of Medicine."