36 Comments
User's avatar
MJ's avatar

Reformed scientist here; this article is absolutely on the button. Needed to be said -- well done.

SMF's avatar

The Nobel Prize is a joke for the omission of Orville and Wilbur Wright. It is a bigger joke for the so-called Peace Prize; Gore, Obama, Yasser Arafat.....sorry, still laughing.

JB's avatar

John Ioannidis deserves a Nobel, but he’ll never get one

Mark Huntington's avatar

More likely the San Quintin prize for narrative demolition.

Heitor Reis's avatar

Vinay is simply stating the obvious. Normally, the awarding of a prize is based on the quality of the recipient, but the choice among many eligible candidates depends on many accidental factors. Thus, I also consider that the overwhelming majority of people who receive the Nobel Prize are those who have been most favored by the combination of accidental factors. And in the case of the Nobel Peace Prize, this is glaringly evident!

However, there have been a small number of Nobel laureates who received it due to absolute merit. But there are also a small number of people with absolute demerit who have received the Nobel Prize.

In short, all activities must have references to admire, just as ideologies and religions have their saints.

madrad's avatar

Ultimately these are popularity contests at best and a method of propaganda at worst. Just read up on the history of the “Nobel prize in economics.” Hint: there isn’t one.

Vijay Gupta's avatar

The most important criterion for winning the Nobel prize is that one must serve the interests of the establishment and the established order. This is especially true for the economics and peace prizes.

But even in medicine, if someone had found a cheap home-made remedy for Covid and saved a million lives, they would have likely not won the Nobel since they threatened the pharma industry.

Even today, there are far more effective (and safer) protocols for treating Covid in alternative medicine than Remdesivir and Paxlovid, but they have no chance of winning a Nobel.

Dharini Bhammar's avatar

I'm worried you're alienating the committee!

Kath's avatar

Thank you for this piece. Nice ending with a paraphrase of Henry Kissinger's great quote about academic infighting vs. world politics! Your most trenchant observation is that "you can be a scientist with a poor grasp of the history and implications of science." Similarly, as you have repeatedly said, you can be a practicing physician with little grasp of statistics, e.g., NNT. Both gaps in understanding can lead to harmful outcomes for individuals and for society. One problem with today's Nobels (in medicine and other fields) is the failure of the scientific community to acknowledge that "the Prize" (golden apple) honors a mere snapshot of current knowledge. Even with a thorough look-back at the history of a field of study, one cannot predict whether or not a "new discovery" will be falsified in future. This would be a mere philosophical problem about the limits of human knowledge, except for the larger problem of consensus politics. A scientist is honored. His theory is embraced, often in part a result of the cult of personality. It may take many years for the folly of his idea(s) to come to fruition. In the meantime, many are harmed.

TAS's avatar

This email brought to mind Linus Pauling....who won a Nobel prize... twice. Double luck? And if I remember correctly, he was eventually thrown under the bus when he started using vitc and lysine for heart health issues.

Cranky Frankie's avatar

I ran into Pauling in a hallway waiting to be interviewed on WBEZ (local public radio in Chicago) in the late 80s I think. Recognized him immediately and spoke briefly to him. If memory serves, he was there hawking his latest book about vitamin C. Had a copy in his lap. No entourage, just him sitting alone in a bleak hallway. Probably took the bus to get there.

Mark Huntington's avatar

It was Pauling who actually discovered the structure of DNA - without even trying. He proposed a triple helix but that oak tree was born full-grown.

Cindy's avatar

I see what you did there, referencing Watson and Crick as akin to Everest while simultaneously snubbing Franklin and Wilkins. Well done.

Mark Huntington's avatar

You just snubbed Linus Pauling.

Randy's avatar

Poor Dr pan. Like most Wayne State graduates, we leave lives of quiet desperation.

Neil Steinmetz's avatar

Let’s not forget Raymond Damadian, the inventor of MRI, who received a patent for it. After the importance of MRI had become obvious and the inevitable Nobel prizes for MRI were awarded, although up to three people would have been eligible, only two prizes were awarded, and Raymond was snubbed, likely because he had lobbied for the prize, commercialized his invention and become relatively wealthy, and was generally considered to be something of an asshole.

Jairo-Echeverry-Raad's avatar

Vinay, I largely agree with your point, but it leaves me with a slightly different question:

Where would science —and perhaps human life itself— be if the Nobel Prizes had never existed?

There is something almost paradoxical about a prize created from the fortune of Alfred Nobel, whose name became inseparable from dynamite, ultimately becoming one of the strongest symbols of human intellectual progress.

But perhaps the deeper parallel is with peer review. Both systems try to identify what is valuable in science, and both depend on human judgment. Therefore both inherit the same weaknesses: subjectivity, fashion, prestige, intellectual blind spots, personal bias and, sometimes, plain error.

Peter Ratcliffe’s 1992 rejection by Nature is a beautiful example. The objection was not that the experiment was wrong, but essentially that its significance was insufficient. Twenty-seven years later, that line of work formed part of the discoveries recognized by the Nobel Prize.

So perhaps the real question is not whether Nobel committees —or reviewers— are right or wrong. They inevitably will be both.

The question is: how much scientific progress do we lose when we confuse peer judgment with scientific truth?

And an even more uncomfortable one: we know the stories of the Ratcliffes who survived rejection. How many equally important ideas never did?

AM Schimberg's avatar

It's all popularity contest, the cool kids table, carefully curated.

Raj Batra's avatar

Wish I had this sound advice 4 decades earlier.

I went into Discovery Medicine to shine in the Nobel glitter, and now am reckoning with the question as to whether my life's work (left uncompleted because of "academic politics") is/was a success or a failure.

The perspective of the Nobel as the shining beacon, the holy grail or the divine chalice is illusory, especially as one approaches it within grasp. It's only then that one realizes that it's like the Heisman trophy, not a Superbowl ring.

It's handed to you, not an earned credential.....

Ed Newman's avatar

I am sure there are many scientists and physicists whose work cannot be publicized because the work for the CIA, NSC or Brit and China and Russia equivalents.

Kim Curry's avatar

I highly recommend "Heroes and scoundrels: The good, the bad, and the ugly of the Nobel prize in medicine" by Moira Dolan.