6 Comments
User's avatar
Dr. K's avatar

Vinay, Inspired piece. The two things about public health is that vanishingly little of it serves the public and even less serves health. It should all be shut down and rebuilt from scratch -- or just left shut down if they cannot get there.

Health care is an n of 1 endeavor. Attempting to get beyond that is a difficult endeavor prima facie. Lying about it all (either by omission of important topics) or by actually lying "it will protect you and your grandmother" is an utterly irresponsible failure of morality and any underlying pretension that anything in public health is about health or the public.

You are right. It has become a political (and only a political) roadshow that serves one party and none of the public.

Ernest N. Curtis's avatar

Agree. The very term is nonsensical. Shut it down.

Jim Ryser's avatar

As Dr. K knows, I watched “public health” fuel the opiate epidemic. Then add the political edge. I also agree. Public health just needs to be completely shut down. I’ll stick with my PCP who helps design my care WITH me. And since my grandmothers are dead, I don’t much care for emotion baiting. They know that FEAR sells. That’s why I truly loathe the faction.

Theophilus's avatar

Spot on! Keep it coming.

Jon Hepworth's avatar

Thank you Professor Prasad. As an MPH, (UCLA); I opine that public health functions the most effectively and ethically when we adhere to our professional standards. In that mode we are “public health professionals”. But, when we throw standards, rules and procedures into the garbage can so as to act politically; we are no longer professionals, but hobbyists. At this point, there are so many rotten apples that it would be best to abolish the public health profession and reconstruct it from the ground up. My area of specialty, behavioral health probably has the greatest percentage of rotten apples. The rebuilding of Behavioral Health should be overseen by Pamela Paresky, PhD after she becomes appointed to be director of APA after I send APA Board members a letter explaining why Paresky must become the new APA Director.

Michael Plunkett's avatar

Spot on. It’s sad to waste good minds opining on unproven minutiae. Tracking data, investigating infection outbreaks, that should be their remit. They should stay away from policy as that’s a skill set they lack.