35 Comments
User's avatar
Lucy's avatar

MORE book reviews please. Along with Kirn and Taibbi's short story reviews every week, your book reviews will fill the empty hole left over from childhood....

Expand full comment
Charlotte's avatar

"Bibliovoid" is my word to describe that empty space inside after finishing a book that pulls you in like that. It should, in my opinion, be a real word.

Expand full comment
l.nessel-treen's avatar

Thanks for this thoughtful analysis. Coincidentally, I'm reading The Secret History at the moment, and am taking The Goldfinch on vacation to finish it (I started it on vacation in 2019).

Keep those book reviews coming! Cheers!

Expand full comment
Laura's avatar

What a nice and refreshing commentary to read on Thanksgiving morning. I also enjoyed this book tremendously for its moral ambiguity and depth of story and characters. A joy to read.

Life is definitely complicated: my son is famous for having said in first grade that he is grateful for World War 2 because without it his grandfather wouldn't have emigrated to the US or met his grandmother and my son would not exist. A complicated concept a little one. We who live can't help but sometimes marvel at the world and paths that gave us the privilege of life.

Can I also recommend Anathem by Neal Stephenson? I think you would enjoy the book tremendously. It plays out into the future some of these same difficult and interesting moral and technological questions about society and progress.

Have a lovely holiday, friends!

Expand full comment
mimi's avatar

Glad you enjoyed it. My sister-in-law sent us a copy and I couldn't get into it.

Expand full comment
Eveline Raatgever's avatar

Try listening to audio version. It’s done very well

Expand full comment
Caroline Patton's avatar

I listened/read this book on a 3 day car trip. I listened while driving and read at night at my hotel. Switching between the two modes kept me engaged. Loved this book!

Expand full comment
jody's avatar

I read hundreds of pages and could not get into it either for some reason and finally put it down unfinished. I loved that earlier book of hers. I can see her brilliance as a writer but for some reason I just could not love it.

Expand full comment
Shelly's avatar

This is one of my favorite novels. Her writing is so evocative that to this day when I hear Karma Police I am transported to a near-abandoned housing development in Vegas. I can almost feel the scorching heat. And I have a Goldfinch print hanging above my desk.

Expand full comment
Madeleine Armstrong's avatar

I loved this novel. It's one of the few books I've gone back and re-read, which is quite something considering how long it is. I'm surprised you didn't talk more about Boris in your review - he's the standout character for me, the one I really remember.

Expand full comment
Sr's avatar

I think you'd love Mark Helprin, his novels are so intelligent and gripping, deep and thoughtful. I highly recommend SOLDIER OF THE GREAT WAR to start.

Expand full comment
Lizard's avatar

This is great. I did not finish reading Goodfinch but I do think about the parts that I have read and this is review makes me consider returning to the book. It was just too long for a Kindle read.

Expand full comment
Caroline Patton's avatar

Add the audible version and switch between listening and reading. This is how I was able to complete the book.

Expand full comment
Red Hoffman, MD, ND, FACS's avatar

Thanks for this. The Secret History is one of my favorite books (I’ve reread it multiple times over the past 3 decades!) but I couldn’t get into the Goldfinch. You convinced me to try again:)

Expand full comment
Matthew Atlas's avatar

Loved this book! Could not put it down.

Expand full comment
Michael DAmbrosio's avatar

Just bought it.

Expand full comment
Elizabeth Sutton's avatar

Do you have any favorite works of fiction that portray physicians etc? If you are up for any 19th C Brit Lit. I love Wives and Daughters by Elizabeth Gaskell, the protagonist’s father is a doctor and another character is a naturalist. Middlemarch by George Elliot, Dr Lydgate is a fascinating character

Expand full comment
Susan Tew's avatar

I’ve read the book twice and loved it both times.

Expand full comment
Alicia's avatar

Absolutely adored her first book. She’s an excellent author

Expand full comment
Days Like This's avatar

Thank you for this! Will read the spoiler alert after I read the book. And as a 50 something year old who loves to write, how uplifting it was to read your conviction that perhaps the best is yet to come. Happy Thanksgiving!

Expand full comment