50 Comments
User's avatar
E.B.'s avatar

This is overlooking the documented fact that many of these outbreaks have occurred in immigrant populations (in our area it was primarily Ukrainian immigrants) accounting for over 90% of cases.

Additionally, there have been countless reports of people presenting with classic measles symptoms who were not subsequently tested for measles because they were previously vaccinated. That skews the data significantly on who is getting measles and vaccination effectiveness, as well as putting public health at risk.

Amos's avatar

Yes, and I would also question the "status unknown" category. How many of these people just can't find their records? I know I wouldn't be able to produce mine. There would likely be a bias to not look very hard for those records.

Te Time's avatar

I’m glad I had the measles as a child. We had to to go to our cousins house to get it. Same with chickenpox. My brother and I got both at the same time. It was a right of passage and seems to have protective qualities.

ADWH's avatar

Protective until it wipes out your immune system, but OK. I had chicken pox as a child, and it was miserable. No protective qualities there, as now Shingles is a risk.

Karen Shulman's avatar

Yeah but we won’t get chicken pox again! 😁

Karen Shulman's avatar

And a far higher complication and death rate than the vaccine, which also offers durable immunity.

Dadelaide's avatar

Fair point but you would also expect highly publicised outbreaks to lead to surges in vaccination rates. You would also also expect public health officials to strongly drive the messaging of the importance of this vaccine. Do you not acknowledge how deficient Kennedy has been in this regard and ascribe any public health impact from this dereliction of duty?

Mark's avatar

To the first sentence, not really. The people who don't vaccinate their kids do it on purpose and want their children to get the infection and go to infection parties. These people are not affected by outbreaks. They look forward to outbreaks.

And who has been working to decrease vaccine hesitancy by trying to separate the MMR into three components? Why, it's Kennedy. Some parents are afraid of the trivalent vaccine and he's trying to give them another option to get their kids vaccinated.

Demeisen's avatar

Realize that several of these “outbreaks” are, on modest investigation, significantly over stated. Eg PA not that long ago. After the last 7 years, people's healthy skepticism has increased.

The decision was also made before most news cycles.

Kenneth Uncle's avatar

You’re leaving out the fact that Kennedy started publishing articles opposing measles vaccination in 2005/6. His damage was already underway

David Dunn's avatar

When he was an absolute darling of the Left.

Monica's avatar

He fell out of favor because of his anti-vaccine stances. As he became more vocal on that and less focused on environmental efforts, he began losing favor….because the party coalesces around shared policy goals, not personalities.

David Dunn's avatar

It's way more than that.

He was strongly critical of Biden's media censorship during Covid. He also had concerns about escalating military intervention in Ukraine. Not to mention the fact that the primaries and delegate rule changes in 2024 were designed to basically protect Biden. Among other issues.

And as far as "the party coalesces around shared policy goals, not personalities," I will say one word--Biden.

Tonya's avatar

Canada lost their status in 2025 and the UK and Spain lost their elimination status in January 2026. This is not unique to the US. I think there is more at play. I think we are underestimating the effects of having measles and those antibodies being passed on through pregnancy. We know the measles vaccine wanes.

Hansang Bae's avatar

Strange? No. Expected? Absolutely.

After all, Orange man bad. Haven't you heard? You should ask how name if the rise in cases started with tens of millions of illegal aliens pouring into our country.

ADWH's avatar

Ah, yes. Blame it on the illegal aliens. Except there just doesn’t seem to be data to support that. Where are the outbreaks and deaths? Happening in white communities.

ADWH's avatar

Argentina, Bolivia, Chile, Colombia, Ecuador, Guyana, Paraguay, Peru, Suriname, and Uruguayhave maintained continuous measles elimination. Six of the seven Central American countries also have measles elimination status.

I was speaking of things in the US. Why aren’t we hearing about outbreaks and deaths in immigrant communities here?

Hansang Bae's avatar

Explanation is not blaming. And VAST VAST VAST majority of people do not die from measles. I know because I grew up when kids got together to catch measles and get it over with. You don't think those "white communities" hire help from illegal aliens? Just take a walk in Manhattan and you'll see nothing but white kids with latina nanies.

_Jim's avatar

re: "Blame it on ..."

What are measles rates in other countries, in particular, but not exclusively, central and south American countries? Any knowledge or idea what those figures are? You could bolster your case with factual data.

Luc's avatar

"Vaccination status unknown" why don't we clear up that little detail and provide some good numbers????

Hansang Bae's avatar

Because likely they were illegal aliens.

Peter Vogel's avatar

The decline accelerated 20 years ago, when RFK was a prominent amplifier of vaccine–autism distrust.

Paula Amato's avatar

Clearly Trump and RFK Jr are not helping to increase vaccination rates among children even if the decline started earlier. So we can only expect the number of measles cases to continue to increase in the coming years and it will proportionally affect younger people. I look forward to your future article during the next Dem administration blaming the current rhetoric for failing to curb this increase when we had a chance.

_Jim's avatar

Where do these 'measles' contagion originate?

A) From thin air

B) From 'carriers' of the contagion

If the answer is A) then perhaps vaccination is the only answer. (Perhaps.)

If the answer is B) then should we not screen out those carriers for the benefit of all?

Paula Amato's avatar

What do you mean by “screen out”? Regardless of where measles originates, vaccination is going to reduce infection and transmission rates.

Neil Pryke's avatar

Is it really a problem..?

Neil Pryke's avatar

Too much Big Pharma looking for Big Money...

Hansang Bae's avatar

It is for Big Pharma.

Gerry Adams's avatar

Doesn’t that make it worse? The fall from 95 to 92% in the last seven years and the impact on infection rates in teens and the 20+ mean that these rates will get worse and worse in the next 10 years. The tragedy isn’t this this administration caused its - it’s that it doesn’t have the insight to see the trends and take corrective measures.

Edward's avatar

II is not “obviously” preventable via MMR! That is demonstrably false. What is measles? scam. All of it a scam

Benjamin Hourani's avatar

Dear Vinay,

I find myself incredulous you would waste a SM blog as you did today. The point is not who’s responsible for the decrease in measles vaccination rates, but rather that measles has resurfaced . Other than the polio vaccine, and smallpox vaccine I think the measles vaccine is among the best. I’ve personally cared for two adu with measles encephalitis. Both died.

If you have a vaccine that gives you durable immunity with little or no significant side effects why wouldn’t any responsible “Adult” encourage its use -RFK Junior has some degree of responsibility as do others. But instead of hiding his head in the sand, he should be shouting from the treetops that everybody get the measles vaccine.

I couldn’t give a Frick on who’s responsible. But this resurgence should be a wake up call to promote it at every level of government and medical Institutions.

It is very rare in life that anything is caused by one particular event/Individual.But the point is, let’s fix the problem, not the blame

Ben Hourani, MD, MBA

David Newman's avatar

Brilliant and important

David Weinstein's avatar

To politicize this is you falling into a non scientific defense . You have some personal emotional issue with this so proceed to a defense that Trump would have chosen. Rather perhaps you could be more inclusive by including things like the Autism study falsely promoted as fact , Covid causing drop in overall access, as well as a well organized anti vax organization and throw that into the echo chamber of social media. Ask AI why the drop over 10 years. Yes CDC should have fought back better but when you hurl misinformation about autism on a public platform that needs a scapegoat for a horrible healthcare issue without an answer you don’t go and politicize it.

Adele Amisano's avatar

I think the trust in Vaccines, unfortunately, declines once the COVID shot failed to prevent Transmission or sickness.

Donna's avatar

What I want to know is, why not just help to reassure parents and allow the shots to be given separately? Nope, we just have to fight over something instead of allowing a compromise.